Vastaus: PS3, Wii, X360 - kuka vetää pisimmän korren?
Liitän tähän huvikseni Pelit-Onlineen kasaamani läjän Wii-pelien arvostelijoiden mietteistä pelien kontrolleista. Pitäisi selventää, mikä on arvostelijoiden yleinen mielipide kontrollien suhteen, jos ketään kiinnostaa. Varoitus, tulee massiivinen viesti. Suora lainaus:
"Nämä arvostelut on kaikki katsottu Metacritic.comista. Wii-peleistä oli sen verran vähän arvosteluja, että otin mukaan kaikki mitä löytyi, arvosanasta tai sivusta riippumatta, joten tämä ei ole mikään puoleellinen juttu johon on vain hyvien arvosanojen kommentit kerätty. Jokaisen perässä on arvostelijan kommentti pelin kontrolleista. Yritin ottaa mahd. erilaisia pelejä, rallipelin, FPS-pelin, skeittipelin ja tuollainen minipelikokoelma-pelin (EDIT: Ain niin, ja Marvel on messissä myös)
Exite Truck -arvosteluja:
Eyetoychest, 84 pistettä:
http://www.etoychest.org/index.php?o...5398&Itemid=27
"While the controls are removed from the norm, they work surprisingly well most of the time."
IGN, 80 pistettä:
http://wii.ign.com/articles/746/746278p1.html
"the analog steering is handled really well with the left/right and forward/backward tilt functions of the Wii remote"
Gamezone, 80 pistettä:
http://wii.gamezone.com/gzreviews/r29667.htm
"You really have no idea what this game is going to be like until you pick up the remote and drive for the first time. Once youve taken the first step, two feelings will remain: (1) its tough not using an analog stick to steer, and (2) this is the beginning of a racing game revolution."
GameDaily, 60 pistettä:
http://wii.gamedaily.com/game/review...id=5423&page=3
"It's a decent racing game made better by the Wii's motion sensitive controller"
GameSpy, 3 tähteä
http://wii.gamespy.com/wii/excite-trucks/746238p2.html
"Although it takes a little while to get used to the sensitivity of the Wii Remote's steering mechanics, it actually feels good after a while."
Siinä kaikki mitä Exite Truckista oli saatavilla. Game Informerin tynkäarvostelussa ei suoranaisesti sanottu mitään Wiimoten käytöstä, Gamespot ei oikein saanut fiilistä kontrolleihin mutta sanoo kuitenkin "Excite Truck's control and speed give it a good amount of potential, but there just isn't enough of a game here to keep you excited for very long." Joten viisi positiivista, yksi negatiivinen ja yksi neutraali.
Call of Duty 3 -arvosteluja:
PGNx Media, 93 pistettä:
http://pgnx.net/reviews.php?page=full&id=12656
"While the Wii controls work with other games, of the games weve played so far, Call of Duty 3 is the one that most benefits from the motion sensing controls."
Gamezone, 83 pistettä:
http://wii.gamezone.com/gzreviews/r29611.htm
"The Wii controller makes this a laborious, intense experience."
GamingTrend, 83 pistettä:
http://gamingtrend.com/Reviews/revie...p?ReviewID=713
"The Wiimote is one of the most natural control schemes Ive ever used for a shooter, once I spent the time to learn it. Anyone who tells you differently clearly hasnt spent the time to adapt to the new control system."
IGN, 77 pistettä:
http://wii.ign.com/articles/746/746145p1.html
"Still, Call of Duty 3s control is definitely something to experience, and seems to be second only to "Metroid."
Siinä kaikki mitä CoD3:sta oli saatavilla. Neljä positiivista mielipidettä ohjauksesta.
Super Monkey Ball -arvosteluja:
IGN, 84 pistettä:
http://wii.ign.com/articles/746/746040p2.html
"Now that I've played through Banana Blitz, I would not want to go back to the older control configurations."
Gamespot, 83 pistettä:
http://www.gamespot.com/wii/action/s...ml?sid=6161924
"It serves as a great example of how the Wii's uniqueness can be put to good use."
Gamespy, 80 pistettä:
http://wii.gamespy.com/wii/super-mon.../746476p1.html
"The tilt control feels far more intuitive than using analog sticks to direct the motion of your little encapsulated simians, and it works wonderfully."
1up, 70 pistettä:
http://www.1up.com/do/reviewPage?cId=3155333
"How's the control? Short answer: completely great."
Neljä positiivista mielipidettä. Oli myös kaksi lehtiarvostelua, joiden yhteenvedoissa ei juuri kontrolleista sanottu mitään.
Marvel: Ultimate Alliance -arvosteluja:
PGNx, 91 pistettä
http://pgnx.net/reviews.php?page=full&id=12659
"The game works very well on the Wii and provides a good display of the system's controls."
GamingTrend, 86 pistettä:
http://gamingtrend.com/Reviews/revie...p?ReviewID=714
"Even my wife, who is a non-gamer, was able to get into the game thanks to the simple and natural control scheme. If Raven was looking for a way to bring non-gamers into the Marvel world, this new control scheme is clearly the path."
Gamezone, 84 pistettä:
http://wii.gamezone.com/gzreviews/r29425.htm
"The Wii control scheme fits this game very well, and when coupled with a good story and incredible cast, the result is a game that is very entertaining."
Gamespy, 80 pistettä:
http://wii.gamespy.com/wii/marvel-ul.../746480p1.html
"Most importantly, you won't miss your clunky old gamepad and can just concentrate on having fun."
Jälleen neljä kehuvaa arvostelua. Games Radarin 70 pisteen tynkäarvostelussa ei mainittu kontrolleista mitään.
Tony Hawk's Downhill Jam -arvosteluja:
Gamingtrend, 92 pistettä:
http://gamingtrend.com/Reviews/revie...p?ReviewID=716
"With a great control scheme, graphics that dont look ported, fantastic humor, and a whole lot of races to complete, this quality title is worthy of being a member of the Tony Hawk franchise"
Gamezone, 90 pistettä:
http://wii.gamezone.com/gzreviews/r29612.htm
"The controller plays on its side, like the old NES controller, but the control scheme, especially when using the axis sensors of the Wii controller is simple and delightful. The learning curve is small and even the tutorial is entertaining."
PGNx, 87 pistettä:
http://www.pgnx.net/reviews.php?page=full&id=12658
"It literally takes like 30 seconds to get used to the controls in the game and its going to be perfect to show people what the Wii Remote can do."
IGN, 70 pistettä:
http://wii.ign.com/articles/746/746341p1.html
"The controls work, but they need some fine-tuning. Sensitivity customization and the addition of manuals and reverts would help in the future. It seems a bit too basic as is"
Kolme kehuvaa, IGN olisi hieman kaivannut enemmän säätövaraa muuten hyviin kontrolleihin."